postal 2 apocalypse weekend hospital lever

I agree that we are unlikely to ever be able to trust a Tory government, but that’s no argument not to risk doing so now rather than later (they are very likely to win General Election when it comes so….). another “mandated” referendum, which someone has won the right to hold through a General Election) as it establishes all sorts of precedents which could be used against us in a subsequent indyref (and, having used them against England’s much larger population successfully, they are unlikely to be fazed by the thought of doing it to Scotland). We also should not be cheering along any attempt to reverse what they voted for through extra-parliamentary means and/or without reference to the public again (i.e. The English and Welsh populations – despite what recent polls seem to say, we should remember that “Remain” was predicted to win in 2016 – seem unlikely to have changed their minds and we should not be trying to force them to in any case (unless they have a chance to vote for parties offering “Remain” in an election, and take that chance). It’s not the only case for independence it’s just the one that has been pursued at this time. This is the case for indyref 2 in a nutshell. Ultimately, the SNP have pursued a policy since 2016 which recognises that there is an impasse – we voted No in 2014, and then Remain in 2016, and these two are incompatible because (due to English and Welsh desires) it is not possible to have both. Nigel Farage doesn’t give a toss what the media says about him as long as he gets the thing he wants.īut the independence movement is currently led by people who won’t just miss the chance of a lifetime, but are too scared to even stab a boot at it in case they get some bad press or damage their own careers.

Successful politics is about having the courage to make difficult decisions that might attract criticism, in order to uphold your principles and achieve your goals. What does he have to lose? And what do we have to lose by at least finding out? Why wouldn’t he? We know his own voters are (a) absolutely feverishly desperate to get Brexit done, and (b) not bothered about losing Scotland and/or Northern Ireland to do it. “Boris Johnson would never agree such a deal in the first place!” That’s like voting to stay in a burning skyscraper because you’re in a huff that the lifts aren’t working and you won’t walk up a couple of flights of stairs to get to the roof for the escape helicopter. And the people who are strongly against Brexit but only reluctantly in favour of independence: do we REALLY think they’re going to vote against independence, and thereby condemn themselves to Brexit, just out of some kind of abstract cutting-off-your-own-nose spite? Why? Who’d vote against it? Of the 50% of Scottish voters who are currently in favour of independence (or more, depending on the specific question you ask), many of them because of Brexit, which ones would suddenly change their mind and oppose it when it was an absolutely stark and explicit choice between independence and Brexit?įor the people who want independence AND to avoid Brexit, the referendum offers them the precise thing they desire.

“But we’d lose an indyref that was held after we’d enabled Brexit!” And we’d still be protecting them from something much worse. It’s not Scotland’s job, or our right, to override their will. “But it would be immoral to abandon England and Wales!”Įngland and Wales both voted for Brexit, and more importantly poll after poll shows that they still want it to happen despite knowing it’s going to be dreadful. (And also: if only we had someone in our team who was red-hot at legal stuff and could make sure the deal was watertight.) Then why are we currently pursuing a policy that’s entirely dependent on him giving and keeping his word? Presumably that must be a waste of time too. “But you can’t trust him! He’d do the deal then renege on the promise!” We’ve heard them, and they’re all rubbish. Imagine if there was something we could do.Īnd readers, please spare us the awful arguments against the idea of offering Johnson the SNP’s votes (or, now, even just abstentions) in return for the power to determine our own destiny. Companies would entirely sensibly flock across the Irish Sea to enjoy the chance to effectively remain in the EU without the upheaval of leaving the UK, taking thousands of jobs with them, and inward investment to Scotland would tank.Įvery nation of the UK would basically be getting what it voted for in 2016, except Scotland. It would massively disadvantage the country compared to Northern Ireland. The Prime Minister’s new Brexit deal is a catastrophe for Scotland. If only there was a party with enough MPs to turn that round, eh? 16 votes, up to a maximum of 31, you say?

Postal 2 apocalypse weekend hospital lever